Sorting by

×

A respectful Canada has room for disagreement

by | Dec 4, 2019 | News

Ray Pennings,
Vice-President, Cardus
Courtesy of Troy Media

Disagreement is normal, if not necessary, in a healthy democracy. Being intolerant and disrespectful toward those with whom we disagree, however, is fatal to that democracy.

Historically, Canadians have had the Charter of Rights and Freedoms [and the Bill of Rights before it] for protection. That’s especially important for racial, religious, political or sexual minorities, among others.

So it’s worrying to see streaks of disrespect toward some minorities showing up in new Angus Reid Institute survey data, collected in partnership with think-tank Cardus just after the October federal election.

Take, for instance, the finding that almost one-third of voters say it’s unacceptable for a political leader to be personally anti-abortion even if the leader’s views don’t influence policy.

Granted, the finding came following a campaign in which Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer struggled to handle a barrage of media questions and political attacks on abortion.

Even so, almost one in three voters is prepared to tell political leaders not to bother putting their names on the ballot if they aren’t vocal supporters of the status quo in Canada – the absence of any law around abortion.

This view was especially strong among Bloc Quebecois voters, though it also showed up significantly in Liberal and NDP support.

Regardless of where we fall on the spectrum of opinions on abortion, is it not concerning to see some Canadians are willing to reject candidates simply based on one of their personal beliefs about what could be a very difficult issue?

A tolerant and respectful Canada makes room for disagreement.

Streaks of intolerance and disrespect also appeared when the pollster asked for a reaction to “the idea of a political candidate being a person of faith.” Shockingly, 22 per cent of respondents said the idea “repels” them.

Among Bloc voters, half are repelled by religious people running for office, followed by just more than a quarter of Liberal voters.

Thankfully, six in 10 voters say they’re neutral on the question.

There remains a significant portion of voters apparently willing to discriminate against candidates simply because of political hopefuls’ religious beliefs.

Even so, most Canadians seem to have a growing appreciation for one of the best guarantees of a tolerant and respectful society: religious freedom.

It’s a hopeful sign that 62 per cent of Canadians agree that religious freedom makes Canada a better country. That’s up seven per cent since Angus Reid asked about it in 2017.

Meanwhile, just 12 per cent say religious freedom makes Canada worse, which is a two-point drop over two years.

Amid these hopeful signs, it’s possible that Canadians like religious freedom conceptually but grow concerned when the rubber hits the road in a clash with culture.

So, in the thick of a federal election campaign with hot-button issues like abortion and same-sex marriage showing up, Canadian support for the Charter-protected, fundamental human right of religious freedom gets softer.

Consider the findings that almost seven in 10 Canadians told pollsters they were aware of media coverage of the religions of Scheer, a Roman Catholic, and NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh, a Sikh. Much smaller proportions recalled coverage of other party leaders’ faiths.

Fully 51 per cent of respondents said the coverage of Scheer’s religion left them with a worse opinion of him, while just 24 per cent said the same of Singh.

If anything, the coverage of Singh’s religion slightly helped him: 27 per cent say it improved their view of him, while coverage of Scheer’s Catholicism had a net negative effect.

The fact that Singh’s views matched majority opinion on hot-button issues, but Scheer’s did not, may have overridden any Canadian commitment to Charter rights.

But if that’s the case, we’re poorer for it.

The type of thinking that can’t stand even private disagreement on abortion or same-sex marriage, or is repelled by candidates who happen to be religious, is not only anti-Charter, it’s fundamentally a violation of the guiding principles of a free and democratic society.

Closing politics and public life to those who are religious leaves us with a less tolerant society that brings fundamental freedoms into question. Frankly, it’s just as bad as closing the public square to the non-religious or to LGBTQ+ Canadians.

An important mark of a respectful and free society is not how majority views are treated. It’s really in whether someone is free to hold a minority view and still fully participate in public life.

Instead of shutting out or shouting down disagreement – religious or otherwise – let’s engage with each other respectfully, seeking to understand the other. That’s admittedly difficult to do in a world of 15-second soundbites. But doesn’t democracy deserve our best selves,

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Alberta Wide Blanket Classified Ads – Reaching over 64 Newspapers in Print and Online.

CANADIAN PICKERS! Downsizing? Moving? Buying Silver Flatware & Jewelry. We buy all Mint sets, Gold Jewelry, Rings, Chains, etc. Ted or Joy 825-966-4373. Ad ...More

FIREARMS WANTED FOR OUR 2026 AUCTION PROGRAM: Firearms, Ammunition, Accessories, or Militaria. Collections, Estates or single items. For Auction, or Possible Purchase: Contact us: ...More

All real estate types considered. No credit checks done. Deal direct with lender and get quick approval. 403-543-0927; www.firstandsecondmortgages.ca. Ad Category: Services ...More

INTEGRITY POST FRAME BUILDINGS since 2008 BUILT WITH CONCRETE POSTS. Barns, Shops, Riding Arenas, Machine Sheds and more, sales@integritybuilt.com 1-866-974-7678 www.integritybuilt.com. Ad Category: Buildings ...More

ROCKY MOUNTAIN EQUIPMENT IS HIRING: Parts Technicians, Agriculture & Heavy Equipment Techs - Journeyman, Apprentices, CVIP/Truck Techs, Shop and Field positions available. View Open ...More

AWNA – Alberta Weekly Newspapers Association – Your Trusted Service Provider

Alberta Wide Value Ads – Reaching over 1,000,000 Views Weekly in Print and Online.

Reach over one million views

Alberta Wide Value Ads. Contact this newspaper or The AWNA to learn how your business can reach readers at a super low cost. ...More

Cash Paid for gold & silver

I PAY CA$H!! FOR ALL GOLD & SILVER COINS, JEWELRY, BARS, INGOTS, NUGGETS, GOLD Dust, Dental Gold, Bullion, Sterling Silverware, plus anything made of ...More

We Buy Gold!

Gold Jewelry, Gold Chains, Rings, Bangles, Coins, Scrap Gold, Dental Gold.We come to the privacy of your home. No Obligation! Call Joy or Ted ...More

WANTED: COIN COLLECTIONS. PAYING CASH!

Cash for CoinsWANTED Royal Canadian Mint coins, Franklin Mint, US Mint, world sets etc , collector ’s coins,numismatics , Olympic coins, old coins, old ...More

Samantha Erron Gibbon admits she didn’t set out to write a collection of short stories for youth, but “then it came about that the stories I was writing were youth oriented.” The four short stories and one long poem that comprise Gibbon’s debut collection At Ends We Rest are powerful, sad and hopeful. And realistic, […] ...More

Alberta pledges $14M from iGaming revenue to bridge rural-urban casino charity divide, premier announces

Casinos like the Edmonton one promoted here typically earn more money for charities than ones in smaller centres. The premier just announced a new grant to help reduce the disparity. – George Lee, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter A new grant drawing from Alberta’s iGaming revenue will help even the playing field for charities that lack […] ...More

The province hopes to swap roadways with Foothills County in a deal that would give the rural municipality greater traffic control through an increasingly busy industrial area. Devin Dreeshen, minister of transportation and economic corridors, confirmed in an emailed statement that negotiations between the two governments are underway to make the transfer happen. He first […] ...More

The province harbours “no intention of defending Big Tech billionaires” while regulating the development of data centres to serve artificial intelligence, the legislature heard last week. Responsibly developed AI projects have “the ability to deliver enormous wealth creation for Albertans, to put food on the table for Alberta families, to create jobs and to attract […] ...More

Lacombe-Ponoka MLA Jennifer Johnson has made a late-stage appeal to the federal government to save an iconic Prairies institution, reiterating its importance to her riding and agriculture. Johnson noted that the feds have gone against recommendations from a House of Commons standing committee by failing to halt the closure of the 119-year-old Lacombe Research and […] ...More

Kneehill County council divided up millions of dollars worth of unspent grant money after discussing why the money was unspent. General Manager of Corporate Services Will Nyman presented councillors with a report titled allocation of available grant funding to 2026 capital projects, noting in his report staff recently discovered over $7 million in various unspent […] ...More

Two former MLAs for Three Hills — one of them the first woman to serve as a government whip in Canada — were posthumously honoured by the legislature on its resumption last week. Connie E. Ostermann, 90, and Allan Alexander Warrack, 89, both former cabinet ministers in Progressive Conservative governments, received tributes from the legislature […] ...More

All animals at the Fort Smith Animal Shelter have been placed in adoptive or foster homes ahead of the end of volunteer operations, but the future of animal care in the community remains uncertain. The volunteer group running the shelter stopped doing so at the end of last month, having warned for months that the […] ...More

Your Thoughts Are Welcome

Comments for particular stories should go on the comment section below that story. General comments submit HERE

Recent Comments


—— MOST READ STORIES – PAST 14 DAYS ——

CANADA WIDE COMMUNTY NEWS

The encampment near Yellowknife’s downtown sledding hill. The site, one of many criticized by Range Lake MLA Kieron Testart for making downtown increasingly unsafe, is nestled in a small patch of green space, between two [... Read More ]

Casinos like the Edmonton one promoted here typically earn more money for charities than ones in smaller centres. The premier just announced a new grant to help reduce the disparity. George Lee, Local Journalism Initiative [... Read More ]

Premier R.J. Simpson says that not all residential school experiences were the same. (Image courtesy of the legislative assembly) Image courtesy of the legislative assembly One MLA has renewed her call for the GNWT to [... Read More ]

Andres Valenzuela/Toronto Star Bridget Potasky, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter Ontario’s education minister plans to swear in school board trustees under provincial supervision — but a Peel trustee says it’s a tactic to silence them, not [... Read More ]

Samantha Erron Gibbon admits she didn’t set out to write a collection of short stories for youth, but “then it came about that the stories I was writing were youth oriented.” The four short stories [... Read More ]

Kinesiology master’s student, Chanel Cabak, demonstrates using the Hexapod platform device at the University of Calgary on November 3, 2026. SARAH PALMER / LIVEWIRE CALGARY Sarah Palmer, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter The University of Calgary’s [... Read More ]

The auditor general released a report on Nov. 3 stating that Nunavut’s Department of Family Services is failing to check whether homes are safe for foster children in 48 per cent of cases. (William Koblensky [... Read More ]

Infrastructure Minister Vince McKay says that despite the Federal Court of Appeal striking down their bid to keep a South Slave rail line, the GNWT remains committed to returning the service to the NWT. (Image [... Read More ]

Two former MLAs for Three Hills — one of them the first woman to serve as a government whip in Canada — were posthumously honoured by the legislature on its resumption last week. Connie E. [... Read More ]

Miranda Mamakwa of Fort Severn First Nation passed away on Sept. 8 in Thunder Bay. Eva Mamakwa THUNDER BAY — “In this country, when wanton disrespect of life is displayed, people get investigated,” says Julian [... Read More ]

City of North Vancouver councillors and staff join members of the Royal Canadian Legion Branch #118 and the North Shore Veterans’ Council of Canada at the unveiling of a new street banner just days before [... Read More ]