Sorting by

×

‘Fair Deal’ panel gets earful in SL, PR

by | Feb 26, 2020 | News

Locals have their say on ‘fair deal’ concept

Joe McWilliams
For South Peace News

A variety of views and opinions were expressed at the ‘Fair Deal’ meeting in Slave Lake last week.

Not a large variety, because only eight people stepped up to the microphone to tell a trio of government MLAs what they thought. It wasn’t a free-for-all. That was made quite plain by moderator Ken Vanderwell. “Restrict your remarks to the three questions projected on the wall, thank you very much.”

The questions:

  1. Do you think Alberta is getting a fair deal in the constitution?
  2. If not, what would a fair deal for Alberta look like to you?
  3. What should the provincial government do to secure a fair deal for Alberta?

In his opening remarks, Vanderwell explained the goal of the consultation process is to develop a report, with recommendations, for Premier Jason Kenney, by the end of March, “so it’s a tight timeline.”

The timeline for presentations was tight as well – two minutes per person. The first one went well over that, and Vanderwell attempted to rein her in.

When it became apparent that not many people intended to participate, he relaxed the rule a bit. Even so, the whole thing was wrapped up in under an hour.

The first presenter, a woman named Monica, drew a parallel between Alberta’s relationship to Canada and that of the Prodigal Son of Biblical fame. She also likened Canada to a family and the provinces as adult children in that family.

“I believe we have a fair deal,” she said, adding, “Collaboration solves problems.”

Marie was the next speaker.

“Absolutely not,” was her answer to the first question. The Western provinces need more seats in Parliament, she continued. And the equalization system needs to be reworked.

“We’re poorly represented in the Senate, said Craig, pointing out that with 10 million people, the West has the same number of senators as the Maritimes, with a fifth of the population.

Federally-imposed gun control is also something that concerns him.

“An Alberta police force doesn’t make a lot of sense to me,” said Brian.

“Leave the Canada Pension Plan alone,” he added.

Len expressed a fear of separatism sentiment taking hold in Alberta. Creating an enemy of the federal government is not a good idea, he said.

“I don’t think we’re getting a fair deal at all.” said Ann. “I’m tired of us not getting pipelines.”

Wayne agreed.

“We haven’t gotten many fair deals over the years,” he said, mentioning the imbalance in equalization payments.

What would a fair deal look like?

“Everything Quebec gets and more.”

What should the provincial government do?

“Bring home $40 billion, for starters.”

Representing the government at the meeting were three northern MLAs, Pat Rehn of Lesser Slave Lake, Dan Williams of Peace River and Tany Yao of Fort McMurray-Wood Buffalo. The hearing was one of several organized by MLAs around the province, adding to the 10 formal hearings held by the Fair Deal Panel in December and January.

The provincial government has several ideas of what would give Alberta a better deal in the federation. These were listed on a handout at the meeting. They include a provincial police force [to replace the RCMP], the creation of pension plan to replace the CPP, ending the Canada-Alberta Tax Collection Agreement, emulating Quebec in taking greater control of various matters, opting out of federal cost-share programs and establishing a provincial constitution.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Alberta Wide Blanket Classified Ads – Reaching over 64 Newspapers in Print and Online.

CANADIAN PICKERS! Downsizing? Moving? Buying Silver Flatware & Jewelry. We buy all Mint sets, Gold Jewelry, Rings, Chains, etc. Ted or Joy 825-966-4373. Ad ...More

All real estate types considered. No credit checks done. Deal direct with lender and get quick approval. 403-543-0927; www.firstandsecondmortgages.ca. Ad Category: Services ...More

ROCKY MOUNTAIN EQUIPMENT IS HIRING: Parts Technicians, Agriculture & Heavy Equipment Techs - Journeyman, Apprentices, CVIP/Truck Techs, Shop and Field positions available. View Open ...More

INTEGRITY POST FRAME BUILDINGS since 2008 BUILT WITH CONCRETE POSTS. Barns, Shops, Riding Arenas, Machine Sheds and more, sales@integritybuilt.com 1-866-974-7678 www.integritybuilt.com. Ad Category: Buildings ...More

FIREARMS WANTED FOR OUR 2026 AUCTION PROGRAM: Firearms, Ammunition, Accessories, or Militaria. Collections, Estates or single items. For Auction, or Possible Purchase: Contact us: ...More

AWNA – Alberta Weekly Newspapers Association – Your Trusted Service Provider

Alberta Wide Value Ads – Reaching over 1,000,000 Views Weekly in Print and Online.

Cash Paid for gold & silver

I PAY CA$H!! FOR ALL GOLD & SILVER COINS, JEWELRY, BARS, INGOTS, NUGGETS, GOLD Dust, Dental Gold, Bullion, Sterling Silverware, plus anything made of ...More

We Buy Gold!

Gold Jewelry, Gold Chains, Rings, Bangles, Coins, Scrap Gold, Dental Gold.We come to the privacy of your home. No Obligation! Call Joy or Ted ...More

WANTED: COIN COLLECTIONS. PAYING CASH!

Cash for CoinsWANTED Royal Canadian Mint coins, Franklin Mint, US Mint, world sets etc , collector ’s coins,numismatics , Olympic coins, old coins, old ...More

Reach over one million views

Alberta Wide Value Ads. Contact this newspaper or The AWNA to learn how your business can reach readers at a super low cost. ...More

Uneven weather leaves Alberta farmers with mixed harvest fortunes

A farmer seeds his field near Edmonton earlier this year, at the start of a growing season marked by dramatic regional differences in inputs of the climatic kind. A growing season of the good, the bad, the sunny and the wet has had farmers telling varying stories at their local diners, depending on where in […] ...More

Calgary high school student wins national football scholarship

Recipient of the 2026 Glenn ‘Keeper’ McWhinney Scholarship Fund, Jayden McMillan, at St. Mary’s High School on November 10, 2026. SARAH PALMER / LIVEWIRE CALGARY On its way to Sunday’s championship game, the Grey Cup stopped to honour an amateur player on Tuesday afternoon. Although tradition prohibited Grade 12 student Jayden McMillan from hoisting the […] ...More

The two farmers, both neighbours, didn’t see eye to eye on shale gas fracking. One, Stephen Moffett, once ran the biggest pig farm in the country east of Quebec. The other, Beth Nixon, is proud to say her family has owned its rolling hayfields in Penobsquis, a short drive from Sussex, for more than a […] ...More

New SAIT partnership takes students to Panama City to learn from the pros

SAIT’s School of Hospitality and Tourism, located inside of the revitalized John Ware building, as pictured on October 21, 2026. SARAH PALMER / LIVEWIRE CALGARY Calgary hospitality students have gone to Central America to learn about their prospective careers as part of a new-to-the-North study abroad option. Students and staff from the Southern Alberta Institute […] ...More

(ANNews) – As the Prime Minister’s office fast-tracks the Pacific Link oil pipeline under new major projects legislation, First Nations leaders warn that a two-month consultation window compromises free, prior, and informed consent. In a bid to distance Canadian energy interests from the USA, PM Carney and Premier Danielle Smith announced that through the “Pacific […] ...More

Saddle Lake Cree Nation is achieving educational sovereignty

Saddle Lake Cree Nation Chief, Dale E. Steinhauer with a WHINEC member alongside the panel of representatives. John Wirth, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter (ANNews) – Educational sovereignty could soon be coming to the Saddle Lake Cree Nation, ᐅᓂᐦᒋᑭᐢᑿᐱᐏᓂᐣ as the Saddle Lake Education Authority seeks international accreditation for its K-12 schools through the World Indigenous […] ...More

Yellowknife and much of the Northwest Territories can expect conditions that are warmer and drier than normal through November and into December. Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) meteorologist Brian Proctor says there is about a 67 per cent chance of above-normal temperatures across almost all of the territory over the next month, in line […] ...More

Smith backs hybrid ridings as rural leaders warn of diluted voice

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith speaks with media at the 2026 Rural Municipalities of Alberta fall convention in Edmonton on November 3, 2026. Source: David Boles/Great West Media – David Boles, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter Premier Danielle Smith is backing proposed electoral boundaries that would combine parts of Alberta cities with surrounding rural areas, despite concerns […] ...More

Your Thoughts Are Welcome

Comments for particular stories should go on the comment section below that story. General comments submit HERE

Recent Comments


—— MOST READ STORIES – PAST 14 DAYS ——

CANADA WIDE COMMUNTY NEWS

Major federal investments in homelessness, infrastructure and housing, tabled in the 2026 federal budget, are being welcomed by Ontario’s Big City Mayors (OBCM), who have been advocating for help for their communities during these trying [... Read More ]

(ANNews) – A children’s television series is bringing Cree language, Indigenous storytelling and cultural teachings to a new generation through the adventures of a grandmother and her young granddaughter. Created by Métis and Nehiyaw filmmaker [... Read More ]

Frey Blake-Pijogge, right, listens to an Arctic Circle Assembly speaker alongside other Youth. Oli Haukur Myrdal/Arctic Circle Assembly The shaking of hands and small smiles welcome me to Reykjavík, Iceland. So does the rain. I [... Read More ]

Through a combination of adaptive technology and equine therapy, a new project at Squamish River Ranch seeks to remove the barriers that keep mobility-challenged individuals from the deep woods. Stacy Thomas, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter [... Read More ]

(ANNews) – For Edmonton fashion designer Heather Bouchier, fashion has always been more than clothing. It is a creative expression shaped by family, culture, personal inspiration and a legacy she did not fully understand until [... Read More ]

The N.W.T.’s legislature has approved a $795-million territorial capital budget for 2027-28, roughly twice the size of those from recent years. More than half of that money – $424 million – comes from federal contributions. [... Read More ]

Photo by {span}IISD Experimental Lakes Area{/span} Pam Fedack, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter A solar and battery system at the Experimental Lakes Area east of Kenora could save about 80,000 litres of diesel a year, freeing [... Read More ]

With the regional approach to economic development in doubt, Peachland may have to go it alone. Jeff McDonald, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter Economic development refers to government programs and policies that support business growth, create [... Read More ]

(ANNews) – As the Prime Minister’s office fast-tracks the Pacific Link oil pipeline under new major projects legislation, First Nations leaders warn that a two-month consultation window compromises free, prior, and informed consent. In a [... Read More ]

(ANNews) – Prime Minister Mark Carney brought nearly 200 First Nations Chiefs and leaders together with provincial and territorial premiers for an historic meeting focused on economic participation, community safety, infrastructure and the future of [... Read More ]

“What voice do people have?” That was the question that drove many frustrated Mississauga voters to find out if they could change the way City Hall manages their money. “I personally think the voice is [... Read More ]